HMX Caramel Pudding vs. Cherry MX Black
An in-depth look at the HMX Caramel Pudding and the Cherry MX Black switches—which one is the best fit for you?
Overview
When it comes to mechanical keyboard switches, the HMX Caramel Pudding and Cherry MX Black both present appealing options for those seeking a linear switch experience, yet they cater to different typing preferences and sound aesthetics. The Caramel Pudding switch is celebrated for its resonant, clacky sound signature and an exquisitely smooth typing feel, making it an excellent choice for users who enjoy both auditory feedback and a satisfying keystroke. In contrast, the Cherry MX Black switch has been refined with Cherry's new Hyperglide tooling, offering a familiar deep sound profile along with a classic textured smoothness that suits those who prefer a more substantial feel and a lower-pitched acoustic environment. While both switches share the linear characteristic that allows for uninterrupted key presses, their unique sound signatures and tactile experiences set them apart. However, let’s dive in a bit deeper beyond generalities so you can best decide on the ideal switch for you.
By the numbers
Technical specifications
Actuation force
45g
Actuation force
60g
Bottom-out force
52g
Bottom-out force
80g
Pre-travel
2.00 mm
Pre-travel
2.00 mm
Total travel
3.60 mm
Total travel
4.00 mm
Factory lubed
Yes
Factory lubed
No
Stem construction
Standard
Stem construction
Standard
Stem material
POM
Stem material
POM
Top housing material
Nylon
Top housing material
Nylon
Bottom housing material
Nylon
Bottom housing material
Nylon
Mount type
PCB (5-pin)
Mount type
Plate (3-pin)
Spring
22mm single-staged spring
Spring
Stainless steel
Housing materials
The housing materials of the HMX Caramel Pudding and Cherry MX Black switches are both constructed from nylon, providing a consistent auditory experience across both switch types. This choice of material is significant, as nylon is known for its ability to produce a deeper and fuller sound profile. Typing on either switch yields similar acoustic qualities, characterized by a duller and rounder sound due to nylon’s softer nature, which helps absorb more sound compared to harder plastics. As a result, users can expect a relatively quiet and smooth typing experience with either switch, reinforcing that the sound produced is not just about the mechanism inside but fundamentally tied to the materials used in the housing.
Both switches employ nylon for their top and bottom housings, which amplifies the overall sound dampening characteristics and contributes to the pleasurable tactile feedback that many users appreciate. With both the Caramel Pudding and MX Black utilizing the same durable housing material, they provide a well-rounded typing experience devoid of the harshness that can accompany harder plastics. Since the nylon material resonates similarly across both switches, users can achieve consistent feedback while typing or gaming, making each switch a suitable option for those who prioritize sound quality.
Despite the similarity in housing materials, the interaction between the top and bottom housings can influence the overall typing experience. Since the same nylon composition is used in both the Caramel Pudding and MX Black, the differences in qualities like bottom-out feel and release sound are minimal, reinforcing a tangible continuity in performance. Whether opting for the Caramel Pudding or the Cherry MX Black, users will appreciate that both the top and bottom housings work harmoniously to create a refined typing experience focused on minimizing noise while providing satisfying feedback against the fingertips.
Weight
The HMX Caramel Pudding linear switch and the Cherry MX Black linear switch present contrasting profiles in terms of actuation and bottom out forces. The Caramel Pudding has a lighter actuation force of 45 grams and a bottom out force of 52 grams, making it suitable for users who prefer a medium-light typing experience, ideal for long typing sessions or gaming. In contrast, the Cherry MX Black requires a heavier actuation force of 60 grams and a significantly higher bottom out force of 80 grams, appealing to those who enjoy a more substantial push feel with each keystroke. While both switches perform their functions effectively, the weight differences indicate that the Caramel Pudding is better suited for prolonged use due to its lower forces, whereas the MX Black may provide a satisfying tactile feedback for users who appreciate a firmer touch. Overall, the choice between them depends on the user's preference for lighter or heavier switches.
Travel distance
When comparing the travel distances of the HMX Caramel Pudding linear switch and the Cherry MX Black linear switch, a notable difference emerges. The Caramel Pudding has a travel distance of 3.6 mm, while the Cherry MX Black features a longer travel distance of 4 mm. This means that the Caramel Pudding offers a shorter travel distance, which can lead to faster response times, making it an appealing choice for gamers seeking quick key presses. On the other hand, the Cherry MX Black, with its longer travel distance, may provide a more pronounced tactile experience for those who prefer a deeper feeling when typing. Ultimately, the choice between the two switches hinges on individual preferences regarding responsiveness versus depth, with the Caramel Pudding enabling a snappier feel and the Cherry MX Black offering a more substantial keystroke.
Price comparison
Which switch is more bang for your buck?
The HMX Caramel Pudding has an MSRP of $3.50 per 10 switches. At Milktooth, we are able to pass on savings to our customers and offer the Caramel Pudding for $2.99.
The Cherry MX Black comes in at $4.00 per 10 switches.
Here at Milktooth, we offer the best prices on switches (on average, 27% lower the competition). In addition, we offer free shipping on orders over $49.00. We also offer free returns and exchanges, so you can shop with guaranteed satisfaction.
That said, while price is an important piece of the puzzle, our opinion is that you should ultimately pick the option that most suits your unique preferences since you’ll be using these switches for years to come. In other words, finding something perfect for you is, in our view, the most important criteria.
Typing experience
In terms of sound, the HMX Caramel Pudding linear switch produces a resonant, clacky sound that can lend a lively character to your typing experience. This sound signature is particularly appealing to those who enjoy auditory feedback, providing a sense of depth and engagement with each keystroke. On the other hand, the Cherry MX Black switch features a familiar low-pitched sound profile, offering a deeper, bass-heavy tone that is both mellow and subdued. While the Caramel Pudding may create a more vibrant acoustic presence, the MX Black’s sound can be described as more refined and less intrusive, making it suitable for quieter environments.
When it comes to feel, the Caramel Pudding switch is renowned for its exquisitely smooth typing sensation. Users can expect a fluid experience that enhances typing speed and reduces fatigue, making it ideal for prolonged use. In contrast, the Cherry MX Black switches are characterized by a textured feel, introducing a noticeable friction during keypresses. This can give the impression of a more deliberate typing experience. Additionally, the MX Black switches are stiffer, requiring more force to actuate and bottom-out compared to other linear options. This stiffness can be advantageous for users who prefer a more substantial and tactile interaction with their keyboard.
In conclusion, both the HMX Caramel Pudding and Cherry MX Black linear switches offer distinct auditory and tactile qualities that cater to different user preferences. The Caramel Pudding stands out with its clacky sound and silky smooth feel, while the Cherry MX Black provides a deeper, low-pitched sound alongside a textured, stiffer typing experience. Ultimately, the choice between the two will depend on whether you prioritize sound and smoothness or prefer a lower pitch with a more textured feel and greater resistance. Regardless of the select switch, both options can deliver a satisfying typing experience tailored to individual preferences.
Conclusion
To sum up, when choosing between the HMX Caramel Pudding and the Cherry MX Black linear switches, consider your personal typing preferences and usage scenarios. If you enjoy a lighter touch, prefer a smoother typing experience, and appreciate a clacky sound profile while typing, the Caramel Pudding switches may be the right choice for you. Their medium-light bottom-out force of 52 grams makes them easy to actuate, which can be ideal for long typing sessions or gaming where rapid key presses are essential. Conversely, if you seek a more robust and textured feel, along with a heavier actuation force of 80 grams for a more deliberate typing experience, the Cherry MX Black might be more suitable. These switches offer a low-pitched, deep sound that can provide a satisfying acoustic feedback, particularly for those who enjoy a more pronounced tactile response. Ultimately, your choice should reflect not only your typing style but also your auditory preference, ensuring that your mechanical keyboard experience aligns with your personal comfort and satisfaction.
Mentioned in this article
