Gateron Jupiter Banana vs. Kailh BCP

Overview

When it comes to mechanical keyboard switches, the Gateron Jupiter Banana and Kailh BCP provide distinctly different experiences suited for varying preferences among typists and gamers alike. The Gateron Jupiter Banana is a tactile switch that delivers a satisfying feedback with each keystroke, characterized by its polished and resonant feel, enhanced by two-stage springs that promote robust returns and a consistent typing experience. Users who appreciate tactile feedback for heightened accuracy and enjoyment will find the Jupiter Banana an inviting choice, particularly valuing its softer backlight effects for a visually appealing setup. On the other hand, the Kailh BCP is a linear switch that reinterprets the iconic Black Cherry Pie design into a custom-molded format, offering a creamy and bouncy typing sensation that eschews the hassle of disassembly. Its signature poppy and clacky sound adds a playful auditory element, appealing to those who enjoy a smooth and uninterrupted keystroke. With each switch bringing unique attributes and benefits to the table, it ultimately comes down to personal preference. However, let's dive in a bit deeper beyond generalities so you can best decide on the best switch for you.

By the numbers

Gateron Jupiter Banana Tactile

Kailh BCP Linear

$2.80 per 10

$5.00

$4.75 per 10

Learn moreLearn more

Housing materials

The Gateron Jupiter Banana and Kailh BCP switches exemplify contrasting sound profiles derived from their housing materials, particularly in their top housings. The Jupiter Banana utilizes a polycarbonate top housing, which is noted for its stiffer composition that produces a sharper, higher-pitched sound profile. This translucency not only makes it aesthetically appealing, especially when RGB lighting is applied, but also enhances clarity and resonance in sound quality. In contrast, the Kailh BCP features a nylon top housing, which is a softer plastic that absorbs sound more effectively, leading to a deeper, fuller sound. This stark difference in materials directly influences the auditory experience of the switches, resulting in distinctly different sound characteristics suited to different preferences.

Examining the bottom housings reveals a similarity between the two models, as both the Jupiter Banana and BCP utilize nylon for this component. The shared use of nylon leads to a consistent sonic trait of a deeper and rounder sound profile when typing, as the material’s softer texture effectively dampens sound resonance. This means that, despite their differences in the top housing, the two switches will likely exhibit similar bottom-out sounds because the nylon's acoustic properties play a crucial role in this aspect. Therefore, while their overall sound experiences may diverge due to the top housing differences, when it comes to the response felt and heard when the key is fully pressed down, they align closely.

In summary, the combination of a polycarbonate top housing in the Gateron Jupiter Banana and a nylon top housing in the Kailh BCP creates contrasting sound profiles, notably affecting the auditory experience during key release. However, both models feature nylon bottom housings, which provide a shared characteristic of a deep, full sound signature upon bottoming out. This juxtaposition illustrates how distinct housing materials can lead to divergent acoustic signatures, while also highlighting their interconnected nature in producing an overall typing experience that combines unique top and common bottom characteristics. Whether preferring the clarity of polycarbonate or the richness of nylon, the choice between these two switches ultimately relies on personal preference for sound and feel.

Weight

When comparing the Gateron Jupiter Banana tactile switch and the Kailh BCP linear switch, we see distinct differences in their actuation and bottom out forces. The Jupiter Banana has an actuation force of 59 grams and a bottom out force of 69 grams, making it a medium-heavy switch that requires more pressure to both actuate and bottom out compared to the BCP. In contrast, the Kailh BCP features a lighter actuation force of 52 grams and a bottom out force of 63.5 grams, categorizing it as a medium-heavy switch as well but leaning towards a slightly lighter touch. This difference in weight may appeal to different types of users; individuals who prefer a lighter switch for prolonged use might gravitate towards the BCP due to its lower actuation force. Conversely, those who enjoy a firmer keypress may find the heavier feel of the Jupiter Banana more satisfying. Overall, while both switches have similar medium-heavy classifications, the BCP is the lighter option, making it potentially more suitable for lengthy typing or gaming sessions.

Travel distance

When comparing the travel distance of the Gateron Jupiter Banana tactile switch and the Kailh BCP linear switch, we find that the Jupiter Banana has a travel distance of 3.4 mm, while the BCP has a slightly longer travel distance of 3.5 mm. This means that the Jupiter Banana is the shorter option by 0.1 mm, which may appeal more to gamers seeking quicker response times, as shorter travel distances can enhance the feeling of responsiveness. Conversely, the BCP's longer travel distance may be preferred by users who enjoy a more substantial, hearty depth when typing. Ultimately, both switches can generate satisfying results, but the choice between them will depend on individual preferences for travel distance and typing feel.

Price comparison

Typing experience

When it comes to sound, the Gateron Jupiter Banana tactile switch offers a distinct high-pitched and resonant audio profile. Its sharp and crisp sound enhances the overall typing experience, providing an immersive auditory sensation that many users find satisfying. The emphasis on a clean sound makes it appealing to those who prefer a more refined auditory experience without the deep, bassy tones that some switches emit. In contrast, while the Kailh BCP linear switch does not have a detailed sound profile available, it is worth noting that linear switches typically tend to be quieter than tactile or clicky switches. This means users might find the BCP to be less intrusive in sound, which could appeal to those seeking a quieter typing experience.

Regarding feel, the Jupiter Banana switches shine through their polished and creamy characteristics, allowing for a smooth and refined typing experience. The attention to detail in the construction ensures a sleek key travel with reduced friction, which, combined with a buttery sensation, provides a pleasure-driven typing experience. On the other hand, the feel of the Kailh BCP linear switch remains largely unspecified, but linear switches are often known for their smooth keypresses without any tactile feedback. This could lead to a different typing experience that lacks the tactile bump found in the Jupiter Bananas, appealing more to users who enjoy a fluid and uninterrupted key travel.

In summary, while both the Gateron Jupiter Banana and Kailh BCP switches cater to different preferences, they each offer unique aspects to consider. The Jupiter Banana excels in both sound and feel, creating a nuanced and textured user experience ideal for those who appreciate tactile feedback and rich auditory qualities. In contrast, the BCP may appeal to those who prefer a quieter and smoother performance, though its exact sound and feel characteristics are not extensively detailed. Ultimately, selecting between the two will depend on the individual's typing preferences and whether they prioritize tactile feedback or a more streamlined linear experience.

Conclusion

To sum up, choosing between the Gateron Jupiter Banana tactile switch and the Kailh BCP linear switch ultimately depends on your personal preferences and typing style. If you value a tactile sensation with a distinctive, high-pitched sound that enhances your keystrokes, the Jupiter Banana is your best bet. Its medium-heavy bottom-out force of 69 grams offers a deliberate and satisfying feedback that can aid in typing accuracy, particularly if you enjoy that tactile bump. Furthermore, with its polished and creamy feel, it provides a smooth typing experience that many typists find gratifying, making it suitable for those who spend long hours on the keyboard. On the other hand, if you're inclined towards a linear feel with a slightly lighter bottom-out force of 63.5 grams and are looking for a fun, bouncy typing experience, the Kailh BCP might be the better choice. It delivers a unique poppy and clacky sound that adds a playful element while typing without the interruption of tactile feedback, making it ideal for those who prefer a seamless keypress for gaming or rapid typing. Ultimately, assess what tactile feedback, sound profile, and overall typing experience resonate with you the most, and choose accordingly to enhance your keyboard experience.

Mentioned in this article

Gateron Jupiter Banana Tactile

$2.80 per 10

Learn more

Kailh BCP Linear

$5.00

$4.75 per 10

Learn more