Kailh BCP vs. HMX Silent Sakura - 53g
An in-depth look at the Kailh BCP and the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g switches—which one is the best fit for you?
Overview
When it comes to choosing the right mechanical keyboard switch, the Kailh BCP and HMX Silent Sakura - 53g offer distinct experiences that cater to different typing preferences. The Kailh BCP switches transform the classic Black Cherry Pie design into a modern masterpiece with custom-molded technology. This innovation not only alleviates the need for tedious disassembly but also delivers a uniquely elastic and bouncy feel, complete with a signature poppy and clacky sound profile that many typists find engaging and satisfying. In contrast, the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g is engineered for those who value quietness in their keystrokes, providing a gentle and soft touch that mimics the tranquil sound of raindrops while typing. With a balanced bottom-out force of 53g, these switches are ideal for users who prefer a light yet responsive typing sensation. Each switch serves its own purpose - one for an exhilarating auditory feedback experience and the other for a serene typing environment. However, let's dive in a bit deeper beyond generalities so you can best decide on the ideal switch for you.
By the numbers
Technical specifications
Actuation force
52g
Actuation force
45g
Bottom-out force
63.5g
Bottom-out force
53g
Pre-travel
1.40 mm
Pre-travel
2.00 mm
Total travel
3.50 mm
Total travel
4.00 mm
Factory lubed
Yes
Factory lubed
Yes
Stem construction
Standard
Stem construction
Partial box
Stem material
POM
Stem material
POM
Top housing material
Nylon
Top housing material
Nylon
Bottom housing material
Nylon
Bottom housing material
Polycarbonate
Mount type
PCB (5-pin)
Mount type
PCB (5-pin)
Spring
20mm single-staged spring
Spring
22mm extended single-staged spring
Housing materials
The Kailh BCP and HMX Silent Sakura - 53g switches both feature nylon for their top housing, which contributes to a deep and fuller sound profile during typing. The use of nylon, a classic switch housing material, tends to absorb sound more effectively than harder plastics, resulting in a duller and rounder auditory experience. This similarity in top housing design suggests that users will likely experience comparable sound characteristics when typing on either switch, especially during key release. This shared material choice infers that both switches will produce a rich sound profile due to the inherent sound-absorbing properties of nylon.
In contrast, the bottom housings of the Kailh BCP and HMX Silent Sakura - 53g switches utilize different materials: nylon for the BCP and polycarbonate for the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g. The nylon bottom housing of the BCP enhances the overall sound dampening effect, contributing to a cohesive, more muted typing experience. Conversely, the polycarbonate bottom housing of the Silent Sakura is designed to yield a sharper and crisper sound profile, due to its stiffer nature. This fundamental difference indicates that while the BCP will produce a softer bottom-out sound, the Silent Sakura’s polycarbonate bottom housing will lead to a clearer auditory feedback that emphasizes sharper sounds when keys are pressed.
Ultimately, the experience of using both switches will be dictated by the combination of their housing materials. The open, rich sound of the BCP stems from its uniform nylon structure, facilitating a warm and rounded typing experience. Meanwhile, the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g, with its contrasting polycarbonate bottom, will offer a more vibrant sound while maintaining a deeper response from the nylon top. Thus, while both switches share a similar top housing and therefore a common sound during key release, they will diverge during key actuation due to their differing bottom housing materials. For users seeking specificity in sound and feel, these variations may guide their choice depending on their typing preferences.
Weight
The Kailh BCP linear switch and the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g linear switch offer notable differences in actuation and bottom out forces, which can significantly impact typing feel and performance. The Kailh BCP requires an actuation force of 52 grams and has a bottom out force of 63.5 grams, making it a medium-heavy option that provides a more substantial feel when typing or gaming. In contrast, the HMX Silent Sakura feels lighter with an actuation force of only 45 grams and a bottom out force of 53 grams, categorizing it as medium-light. This lighter weight might suit those who engage in prolonged typing sessions or gaming marathons, as it can reduce fatigue. For users who prefer a stronger push feel for a more tactile experience, the Kailh BCP might be the better choice, while the Silent Sakura offers a more effortless keystroke that benefits quick responsiveness. Overall, the Kailh BCP switch is heavier, making it preferable for those seeking a firmer typing experience, whereas the HMX Silent Sakura is lighter, catering to those looking for ease of use.
Travel distance
When comparing the travel distances of the Kailh BCP linear switch and the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g linear switch, a notable difference is observed. The Kailh BCP features a travel distance of 3.5 mm, while the HMX Silent Sakura has a slightly longer travel distance of 4 mm. This indicates that the BCP switch is the shorter option, appealing to users who prefer a more responsive, rapid keystroke ideal for gaming scenarios. In contrast, the Silent Sakura's 4 mm travel distance may cater to those who favor a more pronounced keystroke experience, providing a deeper feel that some users find more satisfying. Therefore, individuals seeking quick response times might opt for the Kailh BCP, while those who appreciate a more hearty depth in their keystrokes might prefer the HMX Silent Sakura.
Price comparison
Which switch is more bang for your buck?
The Kailh BCP has an MSRP of $5.00 per 10 switches. At Milktooth, we are able to pass on savings to our customers and offer the BCP for $4.75.
The HMX Silent Sakura - 53g comes in at $3.50 per 10 switches.
Here at Milktooth, we offer the best prices on switches (on average, 27% lower the competition). In addition, we offer free shipping on orders over $49.00. We also offer free returns and exchanges, so you can shop with guaranteed satisfaction.
That said, while price is an important piece of the puzzle, our opinion is that you should ultimately pick the option that most suits your unique preferences since you’ll be using these switches for years to come. In other words, finding something perfect for you is, in our view, the most important criteria.
Typing experience
In terms of sound, the Kailh BCP switch offers a signature poppy and clacky profile, providing an auditory feedback that many typists find satisfying and engaging. This characteristic sound can motivate and enhance the typing experience, making it particularly appealing for those who enjoy a pronounced acoustic response as they type. Conversely, the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g is engineered for a whisper-quiet experience, producing a gentle, almost serene sound reminiscent of raindrops. This makes it an excellent choice for environments where noise can be disruptive, appealing to users who prioritize a quieter workspace while still wanting a pleasing auditory sensation. It’s important to consider that the sound profile of each switch is influenced by other factors such as the keyboard construction and keycap material used, which can further affect the overall experience.
When it comes to feel, the Kailh BCP switch is characterized by a creamy, viscous, elastic, and bouncy tactile sensation, allowing typists to enjoy a lively and responsive keystroke. This tactile feedback can enhance the overall typing experience, creating a connection that many find pleasurable and engaging. On the other hand, the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g focuses on a lighter yet satisfying keystroke, balanced with a bottom-out force of 53 grams. This balance makes it appealing to typists looking for a smooth and effortless input without sacrificing the feeling of engagement with each keypress.
In conclusion, both the Kailh BCP and HMX Silent Sakura - 53g switches present unique qualities that cater to different typing preferences. The BCP excels in providing a lively, clacky sound and a bouncy tactile feel, ideal for those who enjoy auditory feedback and active engagement while typing. In contrast, the Silent Sakura - 53g prioritizes a smooth, light keystroke with a serene sound profile, making it perfect for quieter environments. Ultimately, the choice between these two switches will depend on individual typing preferences and the desired balance between sound and feel.
Conclusion
To sum up, when deciding between the Kailh BCP linear switch and the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g linear switch, it’s essential to consider your typing habits and environment. If you prefer a firmer push with a more pronounced auditory feedback, the Kailh BCP's heavier bottom-out force of 63.5 grams and its unique poppy, clacky sound might be more satisfying for you. This switch is ideal if you enjoy that “traditional” mechanical keyboard feel, where each keystroke feels deliberate and offers a more substantial tactile experience. On the other hand, if you value a quieter typing experience or work in shared spaces where noise may be an issue, the Silent Sakura with its smooth, light, and whisper-quiet operation is a perfect choice. With a bottom-out force of 53 grams, it provides a cushioned feel that promotes faster typing without the distraction of sound. Therefore, your choice should reflect whether you prioritize acoustic feedback and tactile weight or if silence and a soft touch are paramount to your typing comfort.
Mentioned in this article
