HMX KD200 vs. Gateron Smoothie

Overview

When choosing a mechanical keyboard switch, one may find themselves torn between the HMX KD200 and the Gateron Smoothie, both of which fall into the category of linear switches yet offer distinct experiences. The KD200 stands out as the clackiest member of the HMX Film switch family, providing a tactile satisfaction that appeals to those who enjoy a pronounced auditory feedback when typing. In contrast, the Gateron Smoothie is crafted from all-POM material, offering a thocky sound signature that exudes a buttery, smooth feel with a low-pitched and subdued sound—perfect for users who prioritize a quieter typing experience without sacrificing quality. While the KD200 may resonate with those who relish in the characteristic click of a traditional switch, the Smoothie offers a refined, creamy touch that supports long hours of typing without fatigue. However, let's dive in a bit deeper beyond generalities so you can best decide on the best switch for you.

By the numbers

HMX KD200 Linear

Gateron Smoothie Linear

$3.50

$3.29 per 10

$3.00

$2.60 per 10

Learn moreLearn more

Housing materials

The housing materials of the HMX KD200 and Gateron Smoothie switches present a fascinating comparison, primarily in their composition of nylon and POM (polyoxymethylene). The KD200 utilizes nylon for both its top and bottom housings, a material widely recognized for its ability to produce a deeper and fuller sound profile. This is attributed to nylon’s softer texture, which allows it to absorb sound better than harder plastics, resulting in a more muted and rounded auditory experience. In contrast, the Gateron Smoothie features POM housing, which is also praised for its sound characteristics, albeit with a unique twist. While POM also yields a deep sound profile, it gives a slightly different tonal quality that many users find pleasing. Thus, while both materials contribute to deeper sounds, their specific auditory results are shaped by intrinsic properties unique to each material.

When delving into the bottom housings, we find a similar distinction between nylon in the KD200 and POM in the Smoothie. The nylon bottom housing of the KD200 continues to enhance the fullness of the sound, ensuring that when bottoming out, the sound produced remains soft and rounded. Conversely, the POM housing of the Smoothie, while also contributing to a muted sound, might introduce subtle differences in texture and feedback upon keystroke, which many enthusiasts argue enhances the typing experience. When pressing down on a switch, the material characteristics of the bottom housing dominate the physical feedback and sound when bottoming out. Here, users may find themselves preferring the KD200 for its cushioned feedback, while others might favor the Smoothie for its distinct tactile experience.

The interplay of these materials in both switches illustrates how even slight variations can lead to different typing experiences. Despite these differences, it’s possible for users to achieve similar auditory results, particularly if they are seeking a more rounded and deeper sound. Although the KD200 relies on nylon and the Smoothie on POM, both switches perform admirably in producing muted sounds that can enhance the overall feel of a keyboard. Ultimately, the choice between the two may come down to personal preference, where nuances in sound and tactile feedback from the specific material must be balanced against individual typing styles and auditory desires.

Weight

When comparing the HMX KD200 linear switch and the Gateron Smoothie linear switch, notable differences emerge in their actuation forces. The KD200 features an actuation force of 45 grams and a bottom out force of 50 grams, making it a light option ideal for those who prefer to type over extended periods or during lengthy gaming sessions. In contrast, the Smoothie has a slightly lighter actuation force of 40 grams, but its bottom out force remains unknown, leaving a gap in the comparison regarding tactile feedback upon reaching the key's limit. Despite the uncertainty with the Smoothie's bottom out force, it can be inferred that its lighter actuation force may appeal to users seeking a more effortless keystroke experience. Overall, those who favor a firmer push for a more substantial typing experience might lean towards the KD200, while users who prefer a softer touch could opt for the Gateron Smoothie, depending on its unknown bottom out characteristics.

Travel distance

When comparing the travel distances of the HMX KD200 linear switch and the Gateron Smoothie linear switch, it's evident that they differ slightly, with the KD200 having a travel distance of 3.5 mm while the Smoothie measures 3.6 mm. This makes the KD200 the shorter option, offering a more responsive feel that may appeal to gamers or those seeking quicker actuation. In contrast, the Smoothie, with its 3.6 mm travel distance, provides a slightly deeper experience, which could be more satisfying for users who prefer a fuller key press. Overall, while both switches have relatively short travel distances compared to traditional designs, the KD200 is more suited for users favoring rapid response, whereas the Smoothie caters to those who enjoy a little more depth in their keystrokes.

Price comparison

Typing experience

In terms of sound, the HMX KD200 stands out as the clackiest switch within the HMX Film switch family, meaning it likely produces a more pronounced and high-pitched noise when pressed, which some users may find energetic and satisfying. In contrast, the Gateron Smoothie offers a thocky sound signature that is low-pitched and subdued. This combination creates a rich, deep "thud" sound when keys are activated, often described as more pleasant for everyday typing and gaming experiences. Ultimately, the choice between the two will cater to different auditory preferences, with the KD200 appealing to those who enjoy a louder, more pronounced sound and the Smoothie serving those who prefer a more muted thocky experience.

When it comes to feel, the KD200's specific tactile characteristics are not detailed, leaving its precise typing experience somewhat unclear. However, the Gateron Smoothie excels in this department with descriptors such as buttery and creamy, suggesting an exceptionally smooth and seamless keystroke. Users can expect a silky sensation when typing, attributed to quality manufacturing materials or potential lubrication. The Smoothie's design enhances the typing experience, making it feel effortless as your fingers glide across the keys. Without knowing the KD200's feel, it’s challenging to make a direct comparison, but users should anticipate a different typing sensation.

In conclusion, if you are trying to decide between the HMX KD200 and the Gateron Smoothie, understanding their sound and feel is crucial. The KD200 delivers a lively, clacky auditory experience, while the Smoothie offers a more subdued, thocky sound with superior smoothness in feel. Depending on your personal preference for sound and tactile feedback, you may gravitate toward one over the other. Ultimately, both switches will provide enjoyable results, albeit in distinctly different ways, catering to various typing styles and preferences.

Conclusion

To conclude, the choice between the HMX KD200 and the Gateron Smoothie linear switch ultimately depends on your personal preferences and typing style. If you favor a lighter feel and appreciate a clackier sound, the KD200 might be the right fit for you, particularly if you enjoy a more tactile auditory feedback while typing. This switch is excellent for high-paced gaming or for those who wish to enjoy the sound of their keystrokes, as the clackiness adds a lively touch to your typing experience. On the other hand, if you seek a smoother and quieter typing experience, the Gateron Smoothie stands out with its buttery, creamy, and silky feel, ideal for extensive typing sessions or a calmer work environment. Its thocky sound signature provides a satisfying yet subdued auditory experience, making it versatile for both gaming and productivity. Ultimately, consider the kind of feedback and experience you desire—whether it leans towards lively clacks or soft, silky strokes—when making your decision between these two exceptional linear switches.

Mentioned in this article

HMX KD200 Linear

$3.50

$3.29 per 10

Learn more

Gateron Smoothie Linear

$3.00

$2.60 per 10

Learn more