HMX Lucky vs. Gateron Melodic
An in-depth look at the HMX Lucky and the Gateron Melodic switches—which one is the best fit for you?
Overview
When it comes to mechanical keyboards, the choice of switch can significantly influence the typing experience, and two contenders that stand out in their own right are the HMX Lucky and the Gateron Melodic. The HMX Lucky, a linear switch, is renowned for its soft and glittery nylon housing, providing a lightweight and neutral typing experience that many find deeply satisfying. This switch is perfect for those who prefer a smooth keystroke without tactile bumps or audible clicks, making it an ideal choice for quieter work environments or extended typing sessions. On the other hand, the Gateron Melodic brings a new life to the clicky switch category, combining the classic clicky sound with modern advancements like smooth factory lubing and dual-railed stems. This means users can enjoy invigorating tactile feedback and a resonant sound without sacrificing smoothness, making it a great option for typists who love an audible response. While both switches cater to different preferences and typing styles, choosing between them ultimately depends on what aspect of the typing experience matters most to you; however, let's dive in a bit deeper beyond generalities so you can best decide on the best switch for you.
By the numbers
Technical specifications
Actuation force
37g
Actuation force
N/A
Bottom-out force
43g
Bottom-out force
60g
Pre-travel
2.00 mm
Pre-travel
2.00 mm
Total travel
3.80 mm
Total travel
4.00 mm
Factory lubed
Yes
Factory lubed
Yes
Stem construction
Standard
Stem construction
Standard
Stem material
POM
Stem material
POM
Top housing material
Nylon
Top housing material
Polycarbonate
Bottom housing material
Nylon
Bottom housing material
Nylon
Mount type
PCB (5-pin)
Mount type
PCB (5-pin)
Spring
22mm double-staged spring
Spring
Stainless steel
Housing materials
When comparing the housing materials of the HMX Lucky and the Gateron Melodic switches, a notable distinction arises between their top housings. The Lucky employs a nylon top housing, which is known for creating a deeper and fuller sound profile thanks to its relatively soft plastic composition. This material absorbs sound more effectively than harder plastics, leading to a duller and rounder auditory experience when typing. In contrast, the Melodic features a polycarbonate top housing, prized for its stiffer nature, providing a sharper, higher-pitched, and crisper sound profile. This stark difference between the materials suggests that typing on the Lucky will yield a more subdued experience, while the Melodic will produce a bright, resonant sound, making them appealing for different user preferences.
On the other hand, both switches share the same nylon bottom housing, which strengthens the similarities between their overall sound profiles. As noted, nylon is effective at absorbing sound, thus creating that richness and fullness, particularly in the bottom-out sound when the key is pressed down. Given that the bottom housing plays a larger role in the tactile feedback and bottom-out sound of the switch, both the Lucky and Melodic should evoke similar experiences regarding that deeper auditory characteristic. This commonality means that even with contrasting top h
ousings, the switches will still deliver a certain cohesiveness in sound, derived from the nylon bottom's influence.
In summary, the HMX Lucky and Gateron Melodic switches showcase varied sound profiles stemming from their differing top housing materials, yet they converge on auditory experience through the shared nylon bottom housing. While the bow of the Lucky promises a muted sound and gentle feedback due to its nylon composition, the Melodic's polycarbonate top elevates the clarity and brightness of each keystroke. However, both switches will still resonate with that full-bodied sound unique to nylon at the bottom—a factor that unifies them despite their contrasting top layers. Ultimately, users will need to decide based on personal preference for clarity versus warmth when choosing between the two.
Weight
When comparing the HMX Lucky linear switch and the Gateron Melodic clicky switch, there are notable differences in their actuation and bottom out forces. The Lucky switch has an actuation force of 37 grams and a bottom out force of 43 grams, making it the lighter option, which is ideal for users who prefer to type for prolonged periods without fatigue. In contrast, the Gateron Melodic switch has an unknown actuation force but a bottom out force of 60 grams, classifying it as a heavier switch. This heavier bottom out force could provide a more tactile typing experience for those who enjoy a firmer feedback with each keystroke. As a result, while the Lucky switch is advantageous for comfort during extended use, the Melodic's heavier resistance may appeal to those seeking more substantial engagement with their keyboard. Given these differences, users can choose based on their personal preferences for typing dynamics and comfort.
Travel distance
When comparing the travel distances of the HMX Lucky linear switch and the Gateron Melodic clicky switch, it is clear that they differ slightly. The HMX Lucky features a travel distance of 3.8 mm, making it the shorter option, while the Gateron Melodic has a travel distance of 4.0 mm, which is the longer of the two. This difference, while only 0.2 mm, can have a significant impact on the feel and responsiveness of the switches. Gamers who desire quicker response times may lean towards the HMX Lucky with its shorter travel distance, as it can provide a more immediate tactile feedback. Conversely, users who appreciate a more pronounced depth and a fuller keystroke experience may find the Gateron Melodic more suitable due to its longer travel distance. Ultimately, the choice hinges on personal preferences regarding key feel and responsiveness.
Price comparison
Which switch is more bang for your buck?
The HMX Lucky has an MSRP of $3.50 per 10 switches. At Milktooth, we are able to pass on savings to our customers and offer the Lucky for $2.99.
The Gateron Melodic has an MSRP of $6.50 per 10 switches. At Milktooth, we are able to pass on savings to our customers and offer the Melodic for $6.00.
Here at Milktooth, we offer the best prices on switches (on average, 27% lower the competition). In addition, we offer free shipping on orders over $49.00. We also offer free returns and exchanges, so you can shop with guaranteed satisfaction.
That said, while price is an important piece of the puzzle, our opinion is that you should ultimately pick the option that most suits your unique preferences since you’ll be using these switches for years to come. In other words, finding something perfect for you is, in our view, the most important criteria.
Typing experience
When it comes to sound, the HMX Lucky linear switch presents a quieter and more subdued acoustic profile compared to its clicky counterpart, which aligns with the expectations for linear switches. Users can anticipate a smooth, almost whisper-like typing experience that allows for focused work or gaming without the distraction of louder clicks. In contrast, the Gateron Melodic clicky switch offers a striking auditory experience characterized by a resonant, high-pitched sound that is both clean and sharp, echoing the enjoyment of tapping on crisp, crunchy leaves. It combines this with a satisfying click that gives users immediate feedback with every keystroke, making it a delight for those who appreciate pronounced acoustics in their typing.
In terms of feel, the HMX Lucky linear switch is known for providing a neutral and deeply satisfying typing experience thanks to its softer nylon housing, striking a balance that allows for smooth keystrokes without any tactile bumps. This makes it ideal for users who prefer a consistent and fluid typing sensation. On the flip side, the Gateron Melodic clicky switch is designed to deliver a wonderfully buttery feel during use, allowing for smooth transitions between keys while also offering invigorating tactile feedback. This combination creates a dynamic typing experience that feels both snappy and responsive, engaging users in every stroke.
In summary, while the HMX Lucky linear switch excels in offering a soft, quiet, and smooth typing experience, perfect for prolonged use, it stands in contrast to the Gateron Melodic clicky switch, which delights users with its lively sound and pronounced tactile feedback. The decision between them ultimately depends on personal preference: if you seek a serene but satisfying experience, the Lucky is the way to go; if you crave the classic auditory engagement of a clicky switch, the Melodic will not disappoint. Each switch caters to distinct typing styles, ensuring that both options can provide a pleasurable experience tailored to individual needs.
Conclusion
In conclusion, choosing between the HMX Lucky linear switch and the Gateron Melodic clicky switch ultimately depends on your personal preferences and typing style. If you prefer a lighter touch and enjoy a smooth, neutral keystroke, the Lucky with its 43-gram actuation force may be ideal for you. Its softer, glittery nylon housing promises a deeply satisfying typing experience, making it perfect for those who prioritize smoothness and minimal resistance. On the other hand, if you thrive on tactile feedback and the auditory cues of typing, the Gateron Melodic with its 60-gram bottom out force could be the better choice. This switch delivers a resonant, crunchy sound profile paired with buttery smooth actuation, making each keystroke invigorating and immersive. Consider your typing habits, the environments in which you will use your keyboard, and what aspects of your typing experience matter most to you—be it smoothness, sound, or tactile response. By aligning your choice with these elements, you’ll be well on your way to finding the perfect switch for your mechanical keyboard journey.
Mentioned in this article
