Gateron Melodic vs. HMX Silent Sakura - 53g

Overview

When it comes to mechanical keyboard switches, the choice between the Gateron Melodic and the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g showcases the diverse typing experiences available to users. The Gateron Melodic, a clicky switch, revitalizes the traditional clicky switch category with its smoothness, thanks to advancements like factory lubing and dual-railed stems. This results in a typing experience characterized as buttery, resonant, and invigorating, catering to those who enjoy a pronounced tactile feedback and the satisfying click sound that is often favored by gamers and typists alike. On the other hand, the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g offers a stark contrast with its linear design, engineered for a nearly silent typing experience that evokes the soothing sound of raindrops. With a perfectly balanced 53g bottom-out force, these switches are ideal for those who prefer a quieter, smoother keystroke, making them a favorite among professionals and anyone in shared workspaces. Both switches bring unique benefits to the table, appealing to different preferences and settings; however, let's dive in a bit deeper beyond generalities so you can best decide on the best switch for you.

By the numbers

Gateron Melodic Clicky

HMX Silent Sakura - 53g Linear

$6.50

$6.00 per 10

$3.50 per 10

Learn moreLearn more

Housing materials

The Gateron Melodic and the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g switches utilize distinct materials for their top housings, resulting in different sound characteristics. The Melodic features a polycarbonate top housing, which is known for producing a sharper, higher-pitched, and crisper sound profile. This is largely due to polycarbonate's stiffer nature, allowing vibrations to resonate more clearly. In contrast, the Silent Sakura utilizes a nylon top housing, a material celebrated for its softer characteristics. This softness leads to a deeper and fuller sound profile, as nylon absorbs more sound than polycarbonate. This fundamental difference in material properties indicates that while both switches are designed to deliver a satisfying typing experience, the Melodic aims for a bright sonic clarity, whereas the Silent Sakura offers a warmer, rounder acoustic experience.

Examining the bottom housings of both switches reveals a reversal of roles in terms of material usage. The Melodic switch has a nylon bottom housing, which continues its trend of producing a fuller sound profile when typing. This nylon base contributes to a more muted bottom-out experience, aligning with the overall design ethos of the switch. Conversely, the Silent Sakura’s polycarbonate bottom housing imbues it with higher-pitched resonances and a sharper response. As a result, when key presses are bottomed out, the qualities introduced by the bottom housing become prominent. These divergent material choices suggest that the Melodic may fortify an overall muted sound profile complemented by sharper, clearer releases, while the Silent Sakura balances its audible qualities between the pronounced bottoming-out impacts and the deeper character of the return action.

Ultimately, both switches illustrate how the interaction between top and bottom housing materials comes together to shape the overall auditory and tactile experience. In cases where the top and bottom housings feature different materials, the unique characteristics of each are distributed across the switch behavior. Therefore, if a user is looking for a balanced sound profile while typing, the Melodic would likely provide more consistency with its nylon bottom, enhancing the fullness, while the Silent Sakura would present a dual nature with pronounced deeper notes on bottoming out combined with clearer sounds on key releases. The result is a nuanced experience with each switch catering to different preferences, yet both capable of delivering satisfying acoustic outcomes depending on the material configuration.

Weight

When comparing the Gateron Melodic clicky switch to the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g linear switch, there are notable differences in terms of actuation and bottom out forces. The Melodic switch has an unspecified actuation force but features a bottom out force of 60 grams, categorizing it as medium in heft. In contrast, the Silent Sakura switch boasts an actuation force of 45 grams and a bottom out force of 53 grams, placing it in the medium-light category. This means that the Silent Sakura switch is the lighter option, requiring less force to actuate a keystroke, which can facilitate longer typing or gaming sessions without fatigue. The Gateron Melodic, with its heavier bottom out force, offers a more substantial push feel, appealing to users who prefer a firmer response. Ultimately, those who appreciate a lighter switch for extended use would lean toward the Silent Sakura, while those seeking a heftier action may prefer the Gateron Melodic, even though both switches yield different actuation force experiences.

Travel distance

Both the Gateron Melodic clicky switch and the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g linear switch feature the same travel distance of 4 mm, which means users can expect a similar tactile experience when actuating these switches. This equality in travel distance suggests that both switches can deliver comparable keypress responsiveness and overall feel, making them suitable for users who favor a consistent typing experience. Despite differing in their switch types—clicky vs. linear—the shared travel distance allows for a blanket understanding of how far each key travels when pressed down. As such, regardless of individual preferences for switch sound and feel, the actuation journey remains identical at 4 mm for both switches.

Price comparison

Typing experience

When it comes to sound profiles, the Gateron Melodic clicky switch offers a distinct auditory experience characterized by its resonant and crunchy qualities. The high-pitched, clean, and sharp sound combines the nostalgic element of clicky switches with modern enhancements, resulting in a sound that is both crisp and immersive. This contrasts starkly with the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g linear switch, which is engineered for a whisper-quiet operation, reminiscent of soft raindrops tapping against a window. The Silent Sakura emphasizes a serene and unobtrusive typing experience, appealing to those who prefer a quieter atmosphere, especially in shared or office settings.

In terms of tactile feel, the Melodic switch is noted for its buttery smoothness combined with invigorating feedback. The smooth and fluid keystrokes provide an effortless typing sensation, while the pronounced actuation feedback delivers a snappy and engaging experience. This dual quality makes each keystroke feel rewarding and responsive. In contrast, the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g lacks a descriptive evaluation for its feel, but being a linear switch, it typically offers a smoother experience without the tactile bumps and auditory feedback common to clicky switches. This linear design caters to those who prefer an uninterrupted typing experience without any tactile feedback or noise.

In summary, the Gateron Melodic clicky switch delivers a vibrant sound and engaging tactile feedback, making it ideal for users who thrive on auditory and tactile sensations while typing. Meanwhile, the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g focuses on providing a quiet and consistent linear feel, perfectly suited for environments where silence is paramount. Both switches cater to different preferences, and while they can produce distinct experiences, your choice ultimately hinges on whether you value engaging sound and tactile feedback or a quieter, smoother operation.

Conclusion

To conclude, your choice between the Gateron Melodic clicky switch and the HMX Silent Sakura - 53g linear switch fundamentally depends on your typing preferences and environment. If you're drawn to the nostalgic clicky sound and tactile feedback that the Melodic offers, with its engaging auditory experience and invigorating keystrokes that evoke a lively typing sensation, then this switch is perfect for you, especially if you don’t mind the extra sound it produces. The 60-gram bottom-out force strikes a balance that many users find satisfying, making it ideal for both typing and gaming scenarios where feedback and responsiveness are key. On the other hand, if you work in a quieter environment or prefer a more subdued typing experience, the Silent Sakura - 53g is your best bet. With its medium-light bottom-out force of 53 grams, this switch provides a smooth, buttery feel while ensuring that your keystrokes remain virtually silent. Ultimately, by choosing based on your sound preferences and desired typing feel, you'll find the switch that enhances your keyboard experience most effectively.

Mentioned in this article

Gateron Melodic Clicky

$6.50

$6.00 per 10

Learn more

HMX Silent Sakura - 53g Linear

$3.50 per 10

Learn more